TAXCPA.COM
← All posts
Tax Cases

The Fishing Club That Struck Gas

A Pennsylvania hunting and fishing club has owned about 230 acres of forest since 1936. In 2011, it leased the mineral rights underneath. The signing bonus was about $921,800. From 2017 through 2023, the club collected $2,187,980 in gas royalties. In 2022, one year brought in $1,180,656, or 90.5% of everything the club took in. The members spent almost zero hours on the gas. The IRS revoked the club's tax exemption, and the club took the fight to the Tax Court. This is Consolidated Sportsmen of Lycoming County v. Commissioner, T.C. Memo. 2026-109.

The one idea to carry out of this story: the IRS counts what your organization does, not just what your members do. If outside money becomes most of your money, the exemption can go, even when nobody hid anything and every dollar was reported. A club that fishes on weekends and collects gas royalties all week is, in the Tax Court's words, running a substantial activity that is not a recreational one.

The setup in one paragraph

Consolidated Sportsmen of Lycoming County is a nonprofit sportsmen's club incorporated in Pennsylvania in June 1936. It owns about 230 acres of forest and meadow in Lycoming County, on top of the Marcellus Shale gas formation. The IRS recognized it as a tax-exempt social club under section 501(c)(7) in 1981. In March 2011, the club's board voted unanimously to lease its oil and gas rights to Rice Drilling B, LLC. Gas extraction began in December 2016. Over the next seven years, royalties grew into most of the club's income, and its net assets grew by more than $1 million. The IRS examined the returns, proposed revoking the exemption back to January 1, 2017, and then issued a final adverse determination effective January 1, 2023. The club asked the Tax Court for a declaratory judgment. The court sustained the revocation, effective January 1, 2023.

Tax yearMineral royaltiesShare of total revenue
2017 *$232,86658.7%
2018$186,09958.3%
2019$172,63757.3%
2020 *$78,02735.2%
2021$34,08519.6%
2022$1,180,65690.5%
2023$303,61044.6%
Total, 2017-2023$2,187,980

These are the opinion's own figures. The 2017 and 2020 figures (marked *) combine royalties and related rental income from the gas leasing, as the opinion's note explains. In every year from 2017 through 2023, the club's total non-member income, royalties plus other investment income, exceeded 50% of its gross revenue.

Who was Consolidated Sportsmen?

The club was incorporated in June 1936 to promote better fishing and hunting, the conservation of Pennsylvania's forests and streams, and the enjoyment of outdoor life by its members and the community. Its articles said it was a corporation that did not contemplate pecuniary gain or profit to its members. On its land, members used rifle ranges, shotgun areas for trap and skeet shooting, ball fields, camping sites, picnic areas, and playgrounds. They hunted, raised game, fished, canoed, kayaked, and swam. Members also used the club for Civil Air Patrol training and free safety training for police and environmental protection groups. The IRS did not dispute that these activities qualify as pleasure and recreation under section 501(c)(7). In all relevant years, the great majority of the hours the club's members and officers spent on club matters went to these recreational activities. On August 5, 1981, the club applied for recognition of tax-exempt status, reporting $9,600 of revenue from timber and no mineral royalties, and on November 19, 1981, the IRS granted it.

The lease

In March 2011, the club entered into an oil and gas lease with Rice Drilling B, LLC, granting Rice the exclusive right to extract the oil, gas, coalbed methane, and other minerals on and under its land for a primary term of five years. Under an addendum signed the same month, the club received a signing bonus of approximately $921,800 in 2011. The board approved the lease and the addendum by unanimous vote. The lease said no royalties would be paid until the lessee started extracting gas. That did not happen until December 2016. Then the checks started coming, and in some years they were enormous. The club reported the royalties on its returns. It did not hide them.

The money

From 2017 through 2023, the club collected $2,187,980 in mineral royalties, an average of well over $300,000 a year. In 2017, royalties were $232,866, or 58.7% of the club's total revenue. They stayed above half of revenue in 2018 and 2019. In 2021, royalties fell to $34,085, only 19.6% of revenue, but the club's other investment income that year was $66,788, so total non-member income still reached 58% of total income. Then came 2022: $1,180,656 in royalties, 90.5% of everything the club took in. In 2023, royalties were $303,610, or 44.6%, and total non-member income was 54%. The club's net assets grew from $1,874,563 in 2017 to $2,941,648 by the end of 2023, an increase of more than $1 million. In dollars, the gas money had become the club's main business.

The IRS comes calling

An IRS agent reviewed the club's returns for 2016 through 2019. On October 27, 2021, the agent sent a 30-day letter proposing to revoke the club's tax-exempt status, effective January 1, 2017. The club protested on December 6, 2021, arguing that the IRS was misapplying the 35% rule, because almost none of its members' time went to the gas lease. Almost two years later, on September 27, 2023, the IRS Office of Appeals issued a final adverse determination: the club did not qualify as a tax-exempt social club, effective January 1, 2023. The club challenged that determination in the Tax Court under section 7428, which lets organizations ask the court for a declaratory judgment, a court ruling on their exempt status. In its answer, the Commissioner asked for revocation back to January 1, 2017, for the years 2017 through 2023. The parties briefed that retroactivity question, and then, on August 19, 2026, the Commissioner conceded it, filing a notice that the revocation would be prospective only. The case was submitted without a trial under Tax Court Rule 122.

The club's argument

The club's case was simple and, at first glance, sympathetic. Section 501(c)(7) exempts clubs organized for pleasure and recreation, substantially all of whose activities are for those purposes. The club said: look at what our members do. Virtually all of their hours go to fishing, hunting, shooting, and the other recreational activities. They spent virtually zero hours on mineral activities, and the officers spent almost none either. The gas was extracted by Rice, a contractor, not by the members. So, the club argued, substantially all of the club's activities were recreational, and the dollars should not matter. The club also pointed to the IRS's own practice, drawn from a 1976 Senate Finance Committee report, of allowing a club to receive up to 35% of its gross receipts from outside the membership, and argued that the facts and circumstances still favored it.

The court's answer

Judge Gustafson disagreed, and the opinion is a plain-English lesson in how the statute works. First, the statute exempts clubs, not members. The word members does not even occur in section 501(c)(7). A club can act through its members, but it can also act through employees or contractors. If a club hires a contractor to extract minerals from its land, that extraction is an activity of the club, even though no member lifts a finger. As the judge put it, minerals do not extract themselves. Second, dollars are a valid way to measure an activity. The club offered no comparison of recreation hours against mineral extraction hours, because it had no evidence of the hours Rice's people spent. Revenue was the evidence in the record, and the court held that the amount of an activity's earnings can be an important way to measure that activity. Third, substantially all means what it says. The court did not need to decide whether the IRS's 35% guideline is the right line, because this club's royalties often exceeded 50% of its gross income, and its total non-member income exceeded 50% in every year from 2017 through 2023. The statute's phrase is "substantially all," and under any reasonable standard, royalties that often exceed half of a club's income mean it is not true that substantially all of its activities are recreational. The court also noted the history: a 1965 case, Coastal Club, held a social club non-exempt on very similar facts, a club that leased its land for oil and gas and took in profits that overshadowed its dues. And the court drove the point home with a hypothetical: ten kayakers who pool their dues are exempt, but if they run a business to fund the kayaking, or fund half their budget from passive investments that take zero of their hours, or buy mineral land and take royalties to fund half the budget, the club is no longer substantially all kayaking. The court sustained the revocation, effective January 1, 2023.

Questions readers ask

Does this mean a social club cannot earn any outside income? No. The court did not set a cutoff, and it expressly did not decide whether the IRS's 35% guideline is the correct line. What it decided is that royalties that often exceed half of a club's revenue, with total outside income above half in every year, are too substantial to call insubstantial.

Did the club escape tax on the royalties? No, and that was never the question. The royalties are unrelated business taxable income, income the tax code treats as taxable even for an exempt club, and the club pays tax on them whether or not it keeps its exemption. The case decided only whether the club keeps its tax exemption, not whether the royalties are taxed.

The members never touched the gas. Why did that not win the case? Because the statute asks about the club's activities, not only the members' activities. Work done for the club by a contractor counts as the club's activity, just as fundraising done by a hired professional counts as the charity's fundraising.

Did the club lose its exemption all the way back to 2017? No. The IRS first proposed revocation effective January 1, 2017, and asked the court for that date, but on August 19, 2026, the Commissioner conceded that the revocation would be prospective only. The court sustained the revocation effective January 1, 2023.

The checklist: what this case teaches

The bottom line: A fishing and hunting club founded in 1936 leased the gas under its 230 acres, took a signing bonus of about $921,800, and collected $2,187,980 in royalties over seven years, including $1,180,656 in 2022 alone. Its members spent almost no time on the gas, and the club reported every dollar. None of that saved its exemption. The Tax Court held that the mineral leasing was a substantial activity of the club, not a recreational one, and sustained the revocation of its tax-exempt status, effective January 1, 2023. If your club, nonprofit, or business earns serious money on the side, get the structure reviewed before the IRS does it for you. The first case review is free, 15 minutes with a live licensed CPA.

Alex Volkov, CPA

Alex Volkov, CPA is a New York-licensed CPA with over two decades in accounting, focused on resolving IRS tax problems, back taxes, liens, levies, garnishments, and audits, for individuals and businesses in all 50 states and around the world.

Your club, nonprofit, or business earns serious money on the side?

Side income is won and lost on structure, the same ground this case was decided on. Talk it through with a live licensed CPA before the IRS reviews it, not after. The first case review is free.

Source: Consolidated Sportsmen of Lycoming County v. Commissioner, T.C. Memo. 2026-109 (U.S. Tax Court, October 29, 2026; Gustafson, Judge; Docket No. 18549-23X). Full opinion text via andrewmitchel.com (mirror of the official opinion). Corroboration: TaxGirl (November 3, 2026) and Tax Coda weekly digest (November 1, 2026). Framework: Internal Revenue Code §§501(a), 501(c)(7), 511, 512(a)(3), 7428; Tax Court Rules 122, 217.